The behaviour and mentality of the Tralfamadorians raises a few questions:
- Could this mentality that the Tralfamadorians possess be a reality someday or is it a figment of Vonnegut's imagination and something that he wished for the world?
- If humans try hard enough, could the awful times be ignored? Is it really that easy?
- Is this concept of ignoring the bad times and focusing on the good ones, something human beings would want to do? If so, how would it all come together --- where is the starting point to achieving this?
- Can ignoring the bad times and focusing on the good times become a reality?
- Are the Tralfamadorians foolish in thinking this, too optimistic or something else entirely?
Having different perspectives is completely okay. In the book, The Crossing by Michael Connelly, the main character, Harry Bosch, has a very different mentality on a case than his colleague, Mickey Haller. Haller asks Bosch, a retired detective, to investigate a case that surrounds his current client because Haller believes that his client is being framed and is actually innocent. Bosch finds this skeptical and as his private investigation continues, he feels like Haller's client could be at fault. The detective's and lawyer's perspective on the case is on complete ends of the spectrum. The two individuals can represent the Tralfamadorians and human beings because they don't understand one another. The Tralfamadorians don't understand the concept of time that humans have, "They couldn't imagine what time looked like to him, (Vonnegut, 114), while humans cannot understand the way reproduction works for Tralfamadorians, "It was gibberish to Billy" (Vonnegut, 114). This is just like how Bosch doesn't see why Haller thinks his client is innocent.
I found that quote (on p.117) very interesting as well. I tried to think about what would happen to the word in 2015 if we chose to think this way. My conclusion: it would be disastrous!
ReplyDeleteI don't think that we have to go to the extreme, and only focus on the awful times and ignore the good. But I do think that if we only focus on the good, we can't learn from mistakes made in the past bad times, we wouldn't have the opportunity to come together and fix our problems. I think that is is very important that we address the tough times, and be aware of them. However, I also think that it is very important that we do celebrate the good, and be aware that there can be good in the world, and that there is.
So over all I don't think that we want this fantasy of the Trafalmidorians to become our reality, but in addition, I don't want Donald Trump to become our reality either.
I agree with you on the points that we can't learn from our mistakes and our bad times if we don't reflect back on them, and that reflection can't happen without thinking of those incidents. We, as human beings, need to find that middle ground between being too optimistic and too pessimistic instead of having this tug of war type of deal between the two.
Delete